Botched Brownies
Thursday, September 15th, 2011I tried my hand at baking brownies from scratch this evening unsupervised, and It definitely felt like my first baking fail. I was attempting to make Cooks Illustrated’s Chewy Brownies. I have had problems with making box brownies in the past, and it seems my bad luck has followed me into the world of from-scratch baking. From the beginning things went wrong:
- I used the wrong measuring cup and added a 1/4 cup of cocoa powder instead of the 1/3 cup the recipe called for and didn’t notice until it was too late to add more. I tried to add some anyway.
- Once I was well past the point of no return, I realized that I was about 3/4 of a cup short on sugar. After an “emergency” phone call to Matt at his meeting, I substituted powdered sugar for the missing granulated sugar. Who knows what that has done to the texture of the brownies
- The bowl I selected was not quite big enough for all my ingredients so by the end I was spilling quite a bit of flour over the edges as I mixed. My shirt is now a lighter shade of blue.
- I nearly put in two time more salt than the recipe called for. Just before I dumped it in, I realized I was supposed to add 3/4 of a TEASPOON and not a 3/4 of a tablespoon.
- The batter itself tasted pretty bitter before I poured it in the pan. I don’t know if that is because of the espresso the recipe called for, or because I didn’t use the right sugar, or because I added more cocoa at the last minute. But I do know it didn’t taste anything like the box brownie mix I am used to.
- When I removed the brownies from the pan using the aluminum foil sling, the whole thing buckled and created a large crack down the middle of the brownies. (more…)
I got a new pannier for my bike, and I am really impressed! It is a gorgeous purple bag made by 

